top of page

Abuse of dominant position: when strategy turns into risk

9 MARCH 2026 · KEPLER FORENSIC

In today’s markets, the line between competing and infringing can be thinner than it seems.

 

Put simply, when a company is dominant in the market – that is, it has enough economic power to shape market conditions – and starts to use that power, we are looking at an Abuse of Dominant Position.

 

This topic has become increasingly relevant in Portugal, not least because of the activity of the Portuguese Competition Authority (AdC). The growing scrutiny is not limited to more regulated or more concentrated sectors, such as energy, pharmaceuticals and retail, but extends to other markets as well.

 

Each sector has its own specificities, which are highly relevant for a detailed analysis of each case. The truth, however, is that practices such as predatory pricing, excessive pricing or bundling cut across sectors and are “fertile ground” for complex investigations by the AdC, or by other parties watching for missteps that harm consumers.

 

In these cases, the main difficulty is drawing the line between an aggressive but legitimate commercial practice and abusive conduct. In line with European best practice, the AdC increasingly relies on quantitative tools to assess whether a company actually holds market power, what the effects of its actions are and whether there is a relevant impact on competitors or consumers.

 

For companies, this creates a new risk context, as they need to understand the economic dynamics behind their strategic decisions. At the same time, it opens up competitive advantages for those who base their decisions on structured economic rationale. Companies that build economic analysis into their decision-making can anticipate and mitigate risks, adjust commercial policies, draft more robust contracts and communicate more effectively with the AdC. Conversely, a poorly planned move can result in fines, reputational damage or cancelled transactions.

 

One of the most high-profile cases in Portugal was the conviction of an energy company, ordered to pay around 40 million euros for abuse of dominant position. The complexity of the case lay precisely in defining the relevant market and measuring market power in a highly regulated and technically segmented sector. Assessing market shares in this context requires understanding specific price-formation mechanisms and whether competitive alternatives really exist. More than the size of the company, the key point was determining whether – and how – the conduct had concrete effects on the market, a demanding economic exercise based on counterfactual analysis.

 

Looking ahead, everything suggests that this overall market framework will become even more challenging. The growing “complexification” and dematerialisation of markets introduce new ways of exercising market power and, naturally, new variables will have to be analysed and new methodologies used. In these contexts, the impact of certain decisions may be neither immediate nor visible, but structural and cumulative. In an environment where competition analysis will be increasingly technical and dynamic – already supported today by AI tools – this evolution requires companies to read their competitive position and the economic consequences of their strategies in a more sophisticated way.

 

In short, ignoring competition risk can have severe consequences. Fines of up to 10% of turnover, substantial damages, cancelled contracts, remedies imposed by the AdC and reputational damage that is hard to repair are not theoretical scenarios but growing realities in the market. In a context of digitalisation and increasing scrutiny, a poorly assessed decision can compromise years of strategy and investment. Today, competition risk is financial, reputational and structural.

 

← Back to Media

bottom of page